Saturday, May 14, 2011

Questions And Answers: Running

I always get a lot of questions on cardio in general and running in particular, so I thought running would make a great topic for my next Q and A.  As always, if you are initiating an exercise program, check with your doctor to make sure it is safe to do so.

Is running a good exercise for weight loss?

Yes and no.  As far as its effectiveness, running is great for weight loss.  You burn a ton of calories.  However, it is high impact and over time can be very tough on the body.  When we run, we put up to 6 times our body weight on our joints.  I’m about 190 lbs, so when I run, I’m pounding my knees, hips, back and ankles with the equivalent of over 1100 pounds of joint stress!  I don’t think our bodies were designed to deal with this level of impact, particularly if you run long distances multiple times per week.  I have found if someone runs long enough and far enough, year after year, they will surely have to deal with some major overuse injuries that can have a negative impact on their ability to engage in physical activity as they age.

I think I want to run a marathon, should I?

I always try to talk my clients out of running marathons.  I get the challenge and sense of accomplishment that goes with running one, but I just don’t think it’s safe.  I’ve already covered the joint stress issue.  Another issue is the effect of that amount of exercise on immune function.  The graph of exercise and immune function is J-shaped.  Your immune system starts to improve with increasing exercise.   However, after a point, immune function starts to decline with increasing exercise.  It even gets to a point below the baseline.  What that means is exercising too much can be worse for your immune system than not exercising at all.  Ever notice how most marathon runners get an upper respiratory infection after the race?  I’m not a fan of any activity that depresses immune function. 

What if I just love to run?

I’ve worked with enough clients over the years to know that running is really addicting and many people will do it despite my recommendation not to.  In this case I would suggest a modified run/walk program.  What I have them do is run for 2 minutes at a pace a little faster than normal and then follow this with 3 minutes of brisk walking.  This interval is repeated throughout the cardio session.  With this strategy, you get the increased calorie burn of running but also break up the impact of continuous running.

Do you advise your clients to run?

Never, I always try to talk them out of it.  If they persist I suggest the run/walk program described above.  I also let them know about lower impact forms of exercise like elliptical training.  This form of exercise will give you a similar calorie burn while protecting the joints. 

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Book Review: The China Study

The China Study by Dr. T. Collin Campbell is next up for review.  Dr. Campbell is an accomplished researcher who is a Professor in Nutritional Biochemistry at Cornell University.  Dr. Campbell has published a ton of research papers and has served as a member on a number of government nutrition and health committees.  He is probably most well known for his work on the China Study, which is an ecological study of nutrition and disease among 6,500 people across China.  The focus of this book is what Dr. Campbell learned from the China Study.

Introduction
Dr. Campbell strongly believes that we should eat a very low fat, low protein diet devoid of all animal products.  If you read this blog regularly or have read my book, you know I am not a low fat or vegetarian guy.  In fact, I feel that low fat diets can have a negative impact on our health due to their resulting high glycemic load.  However, in the young field of nutritional epidemiology, I believe it is important to read work that goes against your own personal views to further understand the controversies that make this field so interesting and thought provoking.  The book presents a lot of Dr. Campbell’s research on nutrition and disease.  He then tells you what foods to eat, and goes into a detailed explanation of the problems with nutrition research and policy at both the academic and government level.  Overall the book was well written and an interesting read.

5 Things I Liked About The China Study
1) Points out the dangers of red meat and saturated fat.  One thing we have all learned from low fat diet advocates is that saturated fat and lots of red meat can be harmful.  This book is no exception.

2) Emphasis on fruits and vegetables.  Fruits and vegetables are the best things we can eat to improve our health.  This is stressed throughout the book.

3) Emphasis on whole grain foods.  While I’m not a high carb guy by any stretch, I realize the importance of whole grains in our diet.  The literature is teeming with evidence that whole grains improve our health and reduce risk of heart disease, stroke, diabetes and certain cancers.

4) De-empahsizes dairy products.  Those of you who know my writing know that I’m not a huge fan of dairy. 

5) Nutrition policy section  As a member of a number of government committees on nutrition policy, Dr. Campbell can relate his first hand experience on the competing interests of academia, the food industry, research science and the government’s influence on our food policy recommendations.  I found this section a very interesting read.

What I didn’t agree with in The China Study
1) This books groups all fats as unhealthy.  While certain fats are unhealthy (saturated fat and Trans fat) other fats like mono-unsaturated fat, poly-unsaturated fat and omega 3 fatty acids are extremely health promoting.  I don’t know why he didn’t differentiate the different classes of fats.

2) This book groups all animal proteins as unhealthy.  There is a very big difference in how chicken, salmon, turkey and egg whites treat our bodies when compared to steak, bacon and hot dogs.  Some animal proteins are bad for you and some are not.

3) Very high carbohydrate diets have recently been shown to have a negative impact on HDL cholesterol and triglycerides when compared to more Mediterranean style diets.  This isn’t mentioned anywhere in the book.

4) Very high carbohydrate diets result in a high dietary glycemic load.  The glycemic load has been associated with a variety of diseases in the past 10 years.  There was no mention of this anywhere in the book or even of the glycemic load as a concept.

5) His criticism of the Nurse’s Health Study was baffling.  He feels that NONE of the research out of Harvard tells us anything because of flaws in the design of the study.  I had a hard time understanding this argument.  His study is ecological in nature, follows 6,500 Chinese citizens and measures diet one time via a 3 day food record and he has total confidence in the results.  The Nurses’ Health Study is a prospective cohort study, follows 120,000 American nurses for over 30 years and measures diet by means of a validated food frequency questionnaire that is updated every 4 years to reflect changes in diet.  Every aspect of the Nurses’ Health Study is superior to the China study yet it is given no respect in this book. 

Is The China Study Worth Reading?
Absolutely.  I enjoyed the book and learned a lot.  At the end of the day, low fat diet advocates taught us a lot about a healthy diet: the dangers of saturated fat, red meat and dietary cholesterol as well as the benefits of fruits, vegetables and whole grains.  However, well designed research has added a lot to our understanding about the benefits of healthy fats, lean animal proteins, fish and other sources of omega 3’s and most importantly, a low glycemic load diet. 

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Research Update: Sleep and snacking and disturbing news about omega 3’s

Dietary omega-3 fatty acids and fish consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2011 93:143-50

This study looked at the association between omega 3 intake and risk of type 2 diabetes. Over 36,300 women from the Women’s Health Study were followed for 16 years and during this time there were 2,370 new cases of type 2 diabetes.  Women who consumed the most marine based omega 3’s (.43 grams a day) had a 44% increased risk of type 2 diabetes compared to women who consumed the least (.07 grams per day).  A similar increased risk was found for women who consumed the most fish (4 servings per week) compared to women who consumed the least (1/2 serving per week).

Take Home Message:  This is a very significant finding.  People are going nuts about omega 3 supplementation.  Omega 3’s have been shown to have extremely beneficial effects on risk of heart disease, which is great, but here is evidence that going overboard has the potential to hurt you.  This is not the first study to show an adverse effect of high amounts of omega 3.  Several other well designed studies have shown higher glucose levels and decreased insulin sensitivity in type 2 diabetic patients with large doses of omega 3 fatty acids.   Get your omega 3’s through your diet, as nature intended, by eating a variety of seafood meals 2-3 times per week.  My clients and those who have read my book know that I am not a fan of supplementation in general.  Too many times concentrated nutrients in large dose supplement form create unexpected consequences in humans.  Get your nutrients through your diet and you’ll have nothing to worry about.

Sleep curtailment is accompanied by increased intake of calories from snacks
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2009; 89:126-33

This is a beautifully designed little study on sleep deprivation and subsequent energy intake.  Eleven healthy subjects slept in a sleep lab for 14 days on two separate occasions.  The sleep lab is a controlled environment where physical activity, sleep and energy intake can be strictly monitored.  The subjects were given unlimited access to as much food as they wanted.  On the first 14 day visit they were restricted to 5.5 hours of sleep a night. On the second 14 day visit, they were allowed to sleep 8.5 hours per night.  Besides the amount of sleep, everything else about the two interventions was identical.  The amount of food they ate throughout the two interventions was measured and compared.  When the subjects slept only 5.5 hours a night they consumed 297 more calories per day!

Take Home Message: Get your sleep!  That rate of caloric consumption would result in a weight gain of 1 pound every 12 days.   Several studies have shown that a lack of sleep increases ghrelin levels (a hormone that influences appetite) and decreases leptin levels (a hormone that influences metabolism).  This must not be the whole story because in this study there was no difference in leptin and ghrelin levels.   More research is needed to elucidate the mechanisms at play here but the message is clear: Get your sleep.

Monday, April 4, 2011

Product Review: PT Pro Portable Fitness Bench

I’ve been working with weight loss and fitness clients for over 15 years.  One thing that I have noticed over the years is that people who work out at home do a much better job at sticking with their routine than those that go to a gym.  This is for a few reasons.  Number one is a time issue.  If you have to get in your car, drive to the gym, get changed in the locker room and then do the same thing in reverse, you may have just turned your 40 minutes workout into an hour and 20 minute ordeal.  It’s just too easy to blow off. 

Also, somewhere along the way, gyms became really expensive!  Many gyms here in the Boston area are $70, $80 or even $100 dollars a month.  This adds up.  If you are spending $80 a month for your gym, that is $960 per year or $4800 in 5 years.  If you took 50% of one years gym fees, you can set yourself up with a home gym that will last for decades!

A great start for any home gym is a set of dumbbells and an exercise bench.  Enter the PT Pro Portable Fitness Bench.  This bench is perfect for people that don’t have a lot of space and/or don’t want to look at their exercise equipment on a regular basis.

Here are some of the features and benefits of this bench
#1) It folds up for storage.  The legs of this bench fold up so you can store it in a closet.  This is a great feature if you live in an apartment and don’t want your bench taking up valuable space.

#2) For fitness professionals; it is highly portable.  The bench is lightweight and you can bring it to a client’s home if you are an in-home trainer.

#3) The bench has both incline and decline capabilities so you can add a lot more variety than you can with a simple flat bench.

#4) It is very well made.  I’ve had mine for years and it is holding up extremely well.  In fact, it looks and works as well today as the day I got it.

Cost: It is not cheap at $299 but it is a one time expense, you’ll likely never have to buy another bench.  It’s also a cost saver if it allows you to cancel your gym membership. 

For more information, here’s the manufacturer’s website: http://www.jpdesignandmfg.com/dbID/20.html

I recommend it highly.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Livestrong

As some of you may know, I recently was hired as a free lance writer for Livestrong.com.
Livestrong is a great site that features a ton of useful health, fitness and nutrition information.  It gets over 6 million hits a month!  I figured that I’d share my last 3 articles that were published on livestrong.com as this blog post.
#1) Why is week 2 of weight loss so hard?  In this article I detail some of the reasons that week 2 of weight loss is not as successful as week 1.
#2) The best all around exercise machine? In this article I declare one exercise machine as the king of them all.  Spoiler alert: it’s the elliptical trainer.
#3) Why aren’t I losing weight on my gazelle?  This article explores how to use the Gazelle Exercise Glider optimally for weight loss.
I hope you enjoy the articles and the site and let me know what you think!

Monday, March 14, 2011

Top 5 Items To Include In Your Home Gym

Going to the gym can be a fun and motivating way to stay in shape.  When I was a doctoral student, it was one of my favorite parts of the day because school was both demanding and sedentary and I really needed to release some stress.

Now that I’m working, getting to the gym is a lot more challenging.  I rarely have a chunk of time in my day when I can get to the gym, get changed, workout and then travel home.  The huge crowds before and after work at most gyms have always turned me off.  A great solution for me and many of my clients is to work out at home.  You don’t need to have a lot of space or spend a lot of money.  In fact, if you took 1 years worth of gym dues, you can set yourself up with a great space saving home gym that will last you a lifetime, or close to it.

By working out at home you save money and you save time and who couldn’t use more of those two things?  Therefore, I am dedicating this post to The Top 5 Items To Include In Your Home Gym.

#1) Gazelle Edge Glider: This is a portable, inexpensive glider (very similar to an elliptical trainer) that will totally take care of your cardio needs.  It folds up for easy storage, costs around $100 with free shipping from amazon.com, and is all around awesome!  I’ve been using one for my cardio for years and love it.  I’d say about 80% of my clients also pick it up and love it too.  I dedicated an entire blog post to the Gazelle.  Here it is

#2) Free weights:  Nothing beats these, period!  For the ladies, pick up a set of 5’s and 8’s.  For the guys, pick up some adjustable free weights that are plate loaded.  They sell these at sporting goods stores.  I’d say get a set that will allow you to go up to 40 pounds or so.  If you want to spend the money, you can also get the spin lock weights from Bowflex or Powerblock.  These can be a bit pricey and they don’t really do anything more for you than free weights but are definitely more convenient and take up less space.

#3) Exercise bands: The one body part that is difficult to exercise at home is your back.  While there are a variety of free weight exercises that target the back, nothing beats the pulling exercises of the lat pull down machine.  A good set of exercise bands takes care of this nicely.  I have Bodylastics bands that come with a door anchor.  This allows your bedroom door to become a high or low back machine.  They are a bargain at $45 on amazon.com. Check them out here

#4) PT Pro Portable Fitness Bench: This bench is awesome.  It pops up for incline exercises, folds down for decline exercises and the legs fold up for easy storage in a closet.  I have one and love it.  It’s a bit pricey at $299 but it is totally worth it if you are pressed for space. 
#5) Door mounted chin up bar:  You’ve probably seen these on TV.  This chin up bar requires no permanent installation.  It fits on your door frame and you can take it off when your not using it.  I use it with arm slings for ab exercises and it’s also great for chin ups and pull ups.  It is also a bargain at $24 on amazon.  Here's the link

Friday, March 4, 2011

Research Update: Protein, Glycemic Index, And Maintenance Of Weight Lost

Diets With High Or Low Protein Content And Glycemic Index For Weight Loss Maintenance
Larsen TM, et al.
New England Journal Of Medicine 363:2102-13 2010.

Objective: To examine whether manipulating dietary glycemic index and protein consumption has an impact on maintaining weight loss.

Study Population: 773 men and women from 8 European countries that had lost at least 8% of their body weight on an 800 calorie diet.

Methods:  All participants were put on a low calorie diet prior to the study and had lost 8% of their initial body weight.  After this point they were randomly assigned to one of 5 diets:
1) Low protein (13% of calories) and low glycemic index
2) Low protein (13% of calories) and high glycemic index
3) High protein (25% of calories) and low glycemic index
4) High protein (25% of calories) and high glycemic index
5)  A control diet

The goal of the glycemic index variable was a difference of 15 units of dietary glycemic index.  Subjects were monitored for 26 weeks to see which group was able to keep the weight they lost off.

Results:  1) Subjects who were in the low protein, high glycemic index diet intervention were the only ones to gain a statistically significant amount of their weight back. 2) Subjects in either high protein group regained significantly less weight than subjects in either low protein group. 3) Subjects in either low glycemic group regained significantly less weight than subjects in either high glycemic group.

Take Home Message:  First of all, this was a really tightly designed study that made it into the #1 journal in the world, The New England Journal of Medicine.  That alone says a lot about the methods and overall validity of the study design.

This study shows that if you focus on lower glycemic carbohydrates and add a bit more high quality protein to your diet, you’ll have an easier time maintaining your weight loss.  If you’ve read my book or work with me privately, this is old news to you.  I have seen this for years with my own clients. 

Another really interesting finding is that the investigators also watched the subjects for additional weight loss.  Both the high protein and low glycemic groups were more likely to achieve an additional weight loss of more than 5%.  It appears that in this group of subjects, a higher protein and lower glycemic approach improved both the ability to lose weight and the ability to keep it off.