Organically grown
fruits and vegetables are much more expensive than conventionally grown. Many
spend this extra money in an effort to limit exposure to pesticides, which in
theory should reduce the risk of cancer. Is this the case? This interesting
study tried to find out (Reference 1).
The Study
Over 31,000 French men and women had their diets measured and were
followed for a cancer diagnosis for an average of 7 years.
Here are some of the most important results:
Substituting 100 grams (about a serving) of conventional produce with
organic produce each day did not reduce risk of cancer.
When comparing subjects who substituted the most conventional produce
with subjects substituting the least, there was no significant reduction in
risk of cancer.
The researchers also looked at individual cancers. Subjects substituting
the most conventional produce with organic produce showed a lower risk of post-menopausal
breast cancer and skin cancer, but a higher risk of prostate and colorectal
cancer. The only result that reached statistical significance was the reduction
in post-menopausal breast cancer.
Conclusions And Recommendations
The results of this investigation are consistent with the research
literature that I have come across. Although much more expensive, there does
not appear to be much of a nutritional or health advantage to organically grown
produce.
Learning this during my doctoral years was a pretty big surprise to me. I
just assumed organic would be healthier. The research has not shown this to be
true with any consistency. If you are interested in diving a bit deeper, you
can find an earlier blog post here that summarizes previous research on
organic produce and health outcomes.
If you like organic produce and can afford it, there is no reason to stop
buying it. If you are mainly doing it to improve your health, the research
literature hasn’t shown us much to support this idea.
References
1) Berlivet J, G. Meyer, E. Alles, B et al. Consumption of organic compared with
conventional fruits and vegetables in relation to cancer risk. American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2026; 101284.